Client TestimonialsCALL TODAY!   239.970.3250

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

4/20/2024 – DougTarman
Sold a Single Family home in 2024 in Marco island, FL.

Wendy and her team did an excellent job helping us sell our home. Wendy was very knowledgeable about Marco’s housing market. She took time to meet with us and work through the process. Wendy and her team answered questions promptly and supported us every step of the way. We would highly recommend using the McCarty group.

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

4/15/2024 – tbquist
Bought a Single Family home in 2024 in Marco island, FL.

Wendy did a great job listening to our needs, and showed us several houses before we found “the one”. When we did find it, Wendy was very helpful in letting us know the local market knowledge for pricing, and how this home “checked all the boxes”. We negotiated back and forth until near 10pm and Wendy was able to get the home for what we had to spend in our budget. The real expertise came after the buy/sell agreements were signed. Wendy guided us through the home inspection process, and all the Marco island specific ordinances that would make a big difference in insurance costs, termite inspections, getting a dock installed etc etc. I really couldn’t say enough about how well we were represented! We are so glad Wendy was on our team!

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

02/17/2023 – cpmiliano
Bought and sold a Single Family home in 2023 in Naples, FL.

We have used Wendy, Mike, Laurie and the McCarty Group in four transactions over the last three years. Each time the experience has been great. They make you feel comfortable throughout the entire process, are great negotiators and had our best interest at the forefront of every transaction. They know the entire Naples area and are Marco Island experts. My wife and I have become friends with Mike and Wendy, not just clients — and highly recommend them whether you’re buying or selling, on or off the island.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

08/18/2022 – sonnykessegeh46
Sold a Single Family home in 2022 in Marco Island, FL.

The McCarty group including Mike and Wendy McCarty is one of the best real-estate groups we have ever worked with. They are diligent, knowledgeable, and hard working. They were always there to answer our questions and would come over at short notices to show us and help us with anything we have problems with. They are very familiar with the market and know what is going on state wide and also nation wide in the real-estate market. They were able to give us the names of very reasonable and professional maintenance service companies to do minor repairs around the house before we put up the house on the market for sale, they told us what to expect when the house was publish for sale online and guided us throughout the sales and closing process. They constantly kept in touch with the buyers agent to make sure that everything was on track and answered all their questions also. The sale of our house went perfectly with no glitch or problems at all, at the end of the sale we were very pleased with the entire process, the closing was a breeze, the McCarty Group was very helpful every step of the way, from the staging group, agents, the schedulers, office staff and all, we are very happy we choose them. If anyone is looking for a professional team to sell their house or to buy one, this is the company to call, they work seven days a week and are always there to answer questions and help in every way, I will use this team anytime, they are great!!!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

06/17/2022 – Shawna Clark
Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in Naples, FL.
Review for Member: Brook Elliott

I highly recommend Brook, especially in this challenging market!! Brook is a fearless negotiator, easy to work with, and responds quickly. I was able to purchase my home up against multiple offers because of her high level of professionalism, tactful communication skills during negotiations, extensive knowledge of the area, and her wisdom in putting together a rock solid offer. Beyond grateful for the privilege to work with her!!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

04/29/2022 – joasia22

Wendy McCarty and the McCarty group were the utmost kind and professional group with which to sell my home. It isn’t easy selling your sweet condo on the beach. With the market the way it is today, there were many unknowns. Wendy and I traversed these waters together with a great outcome. I never had to search Wendy down. She was always ready to communicate by text, phone, email or in person. Most importantly, she has tremendous experience and skilled in the market. Don’t let her comely ways fool you! Besides this, her supporting staff are outstanding. I would highly recommend Wendy and the McCarty group and would work with her again without question.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

04/07/2022 – maacinc

Bought a Vacant Land home in 2022 in Marco Island, FL.

Mike was great to work with – we felt very comfortable with him and found him to be very honest, trustworthy and reliable. We would highly recommend him!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

03/02/2022 – Harold Bradley

Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Naples, FL.
Review for Member: Nancy Brewer

We were introduced to Nancy Brewer by a mutual friend. Friends live in a nice condominium complex on Marco Island and introduced us to winter here. So we started looking, despite the problems caused by Covid. We monitored homes for months through Zillow and Nancy would run over to do a video walkthrough with us. What I like best about Nancy is her no-nonsense approach not wasting time on “bad” properties. Nancy minced no words on properties that didn’t show careful maintenance, and an idea of remodeling needs based on our preferences. She kept her eyes peeled for homes near Mackle Park, and basically stored our preferences in our brain. She guided us through our thinking about whether to stick to the island or explore homes in Fiddler’s Creek, and the pros and cons. Her advice helped us crystallize our decision. When she toured the home we eventually purchased, we could sense her excitement on the iPhone virtual showing. We were very pleased with Nancy’s guidance.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

01/26/2022 – miklosvh6
Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in Marco Island, FL.
Review for Member: Brook Elliott

Brook was great to work with. She has great knowledge of both the area and the market, including the surrounding areas and how they compare. She was also very responsive and always made herself available no matter the time of day.

01/09/2022 – zuser20150415172612214
Bought and sold a home in 2022 in Naples, FL.

Maria Pizzino of the McCarty Group is a wonderful realtor and I would highly recommend her. She is very friendly, professional, knowledgeable, and responsive. She guides you through the process and makes the buying/selling process go smoothly and stress-free. This is my second transaction using her and I expect to use her for all my future real estate needs in Southwest Florida!

12/28/2021 – mfee647
Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.

We could not have been more pleased with the comprehensive, knowledgeable, professional and effective services delivered by the McCarty team. They provided accurate strategic advice on staging and pricing the property, followed through on all of the details necessary to list, communicated clearly and effectively with my family, and sold the home in ten days! It was an amazing experience, and we could not have been happier with the quality of our representation! Thank you!

10/23/2021 – brittmfg
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.

I highly recommend the McCarty Group, they have the depth to help you from start to finish in purchasing a home. They had the staff to help with all aspects of the buying experience. Starting with the locating the right property for us, also had great recommendations and helped coordinate inspections, survey, insurance, and every other aspect of the purchase of our new home. Thanks Mike, Wendy and the rest of the team for making our purchase such a great experience. Mark and Christina

09/10/2021 – hayes jess0315
Bought and sold a home in 2021 in Naples, FL.
Review for Member: Brook Elliott

Brook was absolutely amazing in showing us homes and ultimately finding us our dream home. She was beyond helpful throughout this entire process, and we could not be more appreciative of her services. She was responsive, attentive, and genuine as a realtor. She had our best interests at heart, and we could have not bought a home without her. Brook knew exactly what we were looking for, and she did everything she could to find it for us. She is very resourceful, which made a huge difference between her and other realtors. Brook is an excellent realtor, and we owe her everything for all her help.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

07/09/2021 – BrentonRigor
Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Naples, FL.

Love the McCarty Group. Our agent Nancy was all about customer service and working with us on anything needed. The communication level made everything go smoothly. Thanks McCarty team!!!

06/08/2021 – smiliansky
Bought a Condo home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Nancy Brewer and Laurie Turns

It was a pleasure to deal with the McCarty Group team. Everything went smooth from the first meeting till closing. Very organized and prompt team, provided us all documents, tips and everything we needed.

06/06/2021 – zuser20160122161950466
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Review for Member: Maria Pizzino

Maria was excellent to work with. From the first phone call with my husband and I until our closing she was incredibly professional and attentive. We originally planned on building in Marco Island. On a whim we decided to look at existing/newly constructed homes. We gave Maria a BIG wish list. Maria took us out and showed us many homes. She was able to show us enough homes that we discovered what we considered the perfect home! The home was new construction and 80% complete. Maria, and the Mccarty group, worked as a team to assist us with each step of the process to complete and close on the home. We are not local to Marco which meant that many times we could not be there to answer questions for the builder. Maria was able to send us recordings of the homes progress along with facetime meeting with the builder! Maria went over and beyond what was expected. I would highly recommend her to anyone who is looking to purchase a home!

Bought a Condo home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Review for Member: Elizabeth Smith

Beth really helped make a stressful buying experience much easier! She was extremely helpful and responsive through the entire process. We highly recommend contacting Beth if you are looking for a little piece of paradise on Marco Island!

Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL

Wendy and her team helped us purchase and sell our Marco Island home. We had a stellar experience on both ends! Both Wendy and her staff are warm and eager to help, and most importantly, they got the job done. We loved living there while we did and we were able to sell quickly and for a great price when the time came for a change. I would highly recommend this group to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Marco Island area!

05/31/2021 – davisfamilyof5
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Elizabeth Smith

From early negotiations for our purchase, and through and beyond our closings, we had a wonderful experience working with Beth and we highly recommend her! We sold a house and purchased a house simultaneously, and Beth represented us for our house purchase. Beth is very knowledgeable about the changing real estate market and she kept us informed. Equally as important, Beth was always positive and very responsive to our questions and needs. No question or request was too small or too onerous for Beth- she took everything in stride. She got things done and kept us on track as well. Very professional with a super kind demeanor. She never forgot about the details or any of the “to do” items. Beth always seemed to have time for us when we called her or sent her a text message. Our simultaneous closings went super smooth during an extremely busy real estate market, and we owe a good part of that to Beth’s efforts. Even post closing, Beth went out of her way to check on us in a most authentic and sincere manner. We could not have been more pleased with Beth’s services!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

05/17/2021 – Bob Eskew
Bought a Vacant Land home in 1999 in Marco Island, FL.

The McCarty Group and Wendy McCarty are a very knowledgeable real estate firm on Marco Island. If you’re looking for a professional team to assist you in your real estate transaction, I would recommend you consider them.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

05/05/2021 – Shari Parker
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Elizabeth Smith

Beth was fabulous! She is extremely knowledgeable about the area, and the pros and cons of certain properties/locations. She sincerely listened to my desires and needs – ultimately leading me to my dream home! She was attentive from the first showing until the day I moved in. I highly recommend working with Beth. She really focuses on the client and is extremely positive and enthusiastic!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

05/05/2021 – Ginger Inas
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Elizabeth Smith

Elizabeth worked very hard to find our home in Marco Island. She accommodated us on a last minute showing and continued to be diligent in presenting homes to us that were in our price range and checked off our wish list. She gave great, honest advice. Because of her knowledge and the amount of time she spent with us , we were successful in buying a home beyond what we expected. We would definitely work with Beth again and highly recommend her.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

05/05/2021 – James Morhard
Bought and sold a Condo home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Maria Pizzino

Maria was all you would hope for in a realtor – honesty, integrity, helpfulness, timeliness, a joy to be around, and all of the five stars mentioned. In this area, a realtor like this is hard to come by. Was burned a few times on Marco Island by realtors so I was skeptical when I first met her. She quickly demonstrated her straight up mid-western values and get the job done attitude. We would all be fortunate to be able to work with a person like her. I will go to her to get my next transaction done in Collier County.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

05/05/2021 – Joe Lupone
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Nancy Brewer

We worked with Fancy Nancy, Nancy Brewer in Marco Island We had a unique buying experience because we bought our house without seeing it live. We toured around with Nancy numerous times and she was patient and attentive-she was great at reading between the lines. I will recommend her to everyone that I know and that is buying or selling a house in Marco Island.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

05/05/2021 – Joe Lupone
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Nancy Brewer

We worked with Fancy Nancy, Nancy Brewer in Marco Island We had a unique buying experience because we bought our house without seeing it live. We toured around with Nancy numerous times and she was patient and attentive-she was great at reading between the lines. I will recommend her to everyone that I know and that is buying or selling a house in Marco Island.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

05/04/2021 – tedbuckles
Bought a Condo home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Elizabeth Smith

You couldn’t ask for a better realtor. Beth is professional, knows the area extremely well, does a good job of listening and understand what you’re looking for and then works hard to find you that dream home. During our home search, we changed our minds no less that four times on whether we wanted a house or a condo. Each time, Beth was patient and understanding with us. In the end, we got exactly what we were looking for…and gained a good friend in Beth as well. Bottom Line – We highly recommend Elizabeth Smith!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

04/30/2021 – jodileja24
Bought a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Maria Pizzino

Maria is a wonderful and responsive agent. She works to get things done, is very knowledgable about local codes, and puts your needs first. She knows so many extras that help someone from out of town make a good decision.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

04/10/2021 – NicoleZenz
Sold a Vacant Land home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Maria Pizzino

Maria Pizzino was very knowledgeable and thorough. She was willing to assist even before I made a decision whether I would even sell at all. She quickly found a buyer and was attentive the whole way.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

01/28/2021 – jstone100
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

We’ve dealt with a handful of real estate companies over the last 20 years in Marco. NONE OF THEM come close to matching the professionalism of The McCarty Group. You would expect the owner and listing broker to take a deep interest in the sale of your property – but the ENTIRE staff at the McCarty Group took an interest in the sale of our property. And from the very first interaction, we felt like they were all our friends – and we had never met any of them. We got the price we wanted and the entire transactional process was one of the more enjoyable real estate sales we have experienced. THANK YOU!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

01/28/2021 – user2065820
Sold a Single Family home in 2021 in Marco Island, FL.

Great experience! Easy, fast and responsive. They knew the market and in return got us more than we could have hoped for. Would definitely use them again.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

12/04/2020 – desaia6
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

First of all the entire experience with McCarty Group from listing to settlement was excellent. Both Mike and Wendy kept us abreast of all the matters related to property while we were away up north. Mike particularly is a great negotiator and a true professional. He worked well with the buyer’s agent and ironed out all their demands and closed the deal to the satisfaction of both parties.The communications were prompt and excellent thru the whole time. Mike very skillfully negotiated our tenant’s lease which was very critical in closing the deal.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

10/22/2020 – papazorz7332
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

After being disappointed working with another local realtor, who was highly rated, we decided to try the McCarty Group. I can honestly say when we compared the two firms it was like night and day. Mike McCarty clearly understands the special Marco real estate market. He guided us through the process and we were impressed with his understanding of our situation and goals. His team kept us informed throughout the listing and showings which resulted in a sucessful sale. It is without any reservation that we recommend Mike & Wendy for any future real estate purchase or listing you may be considering.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

10/19/2020 – jeffm337
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

Negotiation skills

My wife and I were looking for a second home. We met with Wendy to discuss our wants. She was excellent in keeping our desires in mind and only showing us homes that fit our profile. She ended up finding the perfect home for us as soon as it became available. She worked diligently to get our offer in place and accepted before anyone else had a chance. We are thrilled with our new home! If my needs change, or any friends are looking for a new home in Marco Island, I will make sure to contact Wendy and The McCarty Group.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

10/19/2020 – haakepuck
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Naples, FL.

Totally enjoyed working with Nancy and her staff. No pressure sales. Always available when we had questions. Conducted the post-closing inspection of the unit as we are out of state buyers. Would highly recommend Nancy and this group.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

10/11/2020 – lainej615
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

The McCarty group are realtor team of experts! We felt we were in great hands the moment we started to work with them to sell our property on Marco Island! They are responsive and have excellent follow-through. Well done McCarty Group! Many thanks!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

10/09/2020 – racjacoby
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

Would use them again. In fact we are using them again on a another property on the Island. Photos and web presentations were well done. Great Attention to detail. They were effective problem solvers which is essential in the sale of residential real estate.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

10/07/2020 – rstrack
Sold a Condo home in 2020 in Naples, FL.

We purchased this property 5 1/2 years previous to its recent sale and worked with Wendy on both transactions. Her attentiveness (and her associates) is second to none. Would highly recommend the services the McCarty Group provides whether you are selling or buying!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

9/18/2020 – john g murphy
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

The McCarty Group is head and shoulders above any other on the island. 4 home purchases and 2 homes sales and worked with The McCarty Group on 3 of them, would never use anyone else. Thank you Mike, Wendy, Laurie; you all are fantastic!!!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

08/25/2020 – rivergold0
Sold a home in 2020 in Marco, Marco Island, FL 34145.

Mike, Wendy and the whole McCarty Group have done a great job in selling my house. The first day Mike got to my house he said that he will sell it in about a month and on the first week on the market we got and offer and for our surprise it was sold. This is not the first time that we do business with Mike, Wendy, Laurie, Denis, the whole group is excellent, my husband and I highly recommend their experience and professionalism . Thank you for helping us to sell our house!!! Julie and Carlos

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

08/24/2020 – annsterling9
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

The McCartys, Mike and Wendy, are an excellent team. They represented me when I listed my house on Marco Island, and they negotiated a very satisfactory settlement on my behalf in a highly professional manner. They were always responsive, and pleasant to talk to. I highly recommend them. Thank you, Mike and Wendy!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

08/21/2020 – pmilligan588
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

Mike and his whole team made selling a Florida vacation home during a pandemic relatively easy. After we cleared out most of our personal belongings they conducted all the showings and open houses without us doing anything. Any issues were brought to our attention and handled immediately. Big thanks to all of them!

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

08/19/2020 – zpierce17
Bought a Condo home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

Wendy and the McCarty Group were extremely helpful in our purchasing of a Condo on Marco Island. Due to Covid we were unable to travel to Marco, Wendy was able to arrange and provide Condo Tours through Zoom and Facetime. She was extremely knowledgeable of the local market and very responsive to all our questions and requests.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

07/28/2020 – ANNEMARIECANNING2
Sold a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

I would describe my experience as a trifecta. I won in selling a property I’d loved for 32 years , the new owners won a beautiful beach house to carry on the charm and the McCartys won in completing the broker’s task with efficiency, diligence and thoroughly pleasant dialogue.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

07/23/2020 – DOCNOUT
Sold a Condo home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

i had a very positive experience with the McCarty group in the sale of my property on Marco Island. Denis Smith and Mike McCarty know the market in Marco and were very professional in the entire process. i would highly recommend the McCarty group.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

07/17/2020 – user9237484
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

Beth Smith was super friendly as well as knowledgeable about the area. Her expertise regarding specific home features also helped us make the best decision for our family.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

06/17/2020 – davidfieselman67
Sold a Vacant Land home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

Our experience with Wendy has been great. She is enthusiastic, has a charming personality, a winning smile and is a pleasure to work with. She is always available and she is honest. If she does not know the answer to a question, she will immediately do the necessary research and promptly get back to you. She keeps her clients aware of changing circumstances and offers helpful advice. She works with and for her clients and, most important, she was able to sell our property. Five +++++stars.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

06/14/2020 – DeanSt1
Bought a Single Family home in 2020 in Naples, FL.
Primary point of contact: Nancy Brewer

I have used Mike McCarty on a previous condominium purchase. For this purchase I used an associate of his, Nancy Brewer, because of her expertise in the area that I was looking to purchase. Her knowledge and experience helped me narrow down my choices and when it came time to make an offer she helped immensely with her insight of previous sales. I made an offer and she helped negotiate my purchase and my offer was excepted. I certainly would highly recommend her for any real estate transactions.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

04/07/2020 – msjagger83
Sold a Condo home in 2020 in Naples, FL.
Primary point of contact: Nancy Brewer

Nancy Brewer was wonderful to work with. She went above and beyond to help out with things that would have been impossible to handle from long distance. The McCarty Group has the level of professionalism that any seller could appreciate and benefit from.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

03/09/2020 – van452
Bought and sold a home in 2020 in Old Marco Junction, Naples, FL 34114.

The McCarty Group has a very substantial, organized and dependable operation. From beginning to end, our transaction proceeded without any hiccups on their end. Staff is very friendly, efficient, pleasant to deal with and knowledgeable. I highly recommend to anybody thinking about doing a real estate transaction: call Wendy McCarty, Laurie and The McCarty Group.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

03/03/2020 – harryfleishman
Bought a Condo home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.
Primary point of contact: Beth Smith

Beth Smith did an outstanding job. She responded to emails immediately and had answers or found them if she wasn’t sure. She made everything very clear and simple. The entire process was enjoyable thanks in large part to Beth.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

02/29/2020 – BrentonRigor
Sold a Townhouse home in 2020 in Naples, FL.

Sold it fast. Great communication. Hard working. I’m not sure what else you could ask for, the house was sold! Nancy Brewer is the absolute best agent around.

---

Highly likely to recommend | 5.0 Stars

02/25/2020 – brupa7134
Sold a Vacant Land home in 2020 in Marco Island, FL.

Called Wendy about selling our lot on Marco Island and she promptly called back and was very informative about the process and what to expect. The communication was top notch and we sold the lot within 60 days The McCarty Group were wonderful to work with. They were professional and responsive from their listing proposal through to closing. We would recommend them to anyone.

---